Keys Under the Mat cover art

Song · Keys Under the Mat

We Made It Right

“We Made It Right” is track 11 on Rob Matare's R&B album Keys Under the Mat, released October 9, 2026. R&B for everyone who built a house across the ocean: one suitcase, one empty chair and a key left under the mat for whoever comes home.

Rob MatareR&B3:29Home & Faith

“We Made It Right” lyrics

Eleven years of silence.
One phone call ended it.
(we made it right)

My brother and I stopped speaking
over money and a will;
two stubborn oaks, one mother's table,
eleven Christmases gone still.
Then the call came on a Tuesday:
"It's his heart. You'd better come."
I drove four states through the midnight
rehearsing "I was wrong."

All that pride I'd been defending
weighed nothing at his door;
whatever we were fighting over,
I couldn't tell you anymore.

We made it right —
two gray men crying in fluorescent light.
Eleven years dissolved in one "I'm sorry" —
don't wait for the phone call. Make it right.

Made it right. (finally)
At his door. (family)
don't wait for the phone call. Make it right.

He woke up on the third morning,
saw me sleeping in the chair,
said, "You still snore like Papa" —
and eleven years thinned to air.
We talked about the fishing cabin,
about Mama's Sunday rolls;
turns out we'd both kept every photograph —
two archives of one whole.

All that pride I'd been defending
weighed nothing at his door;
whatever we were fighting over,
I couldn't tell you anymore.

We made it right —
two gray men crying in fluorescent light.
Eleven years dissolved in one "I'm sorry" —
don't wait for the phone call. Make it right.

Truth is, forgiveness was sitting in my driveway for a decade,
engine running, waiting on my pride to grab a coat.
If there's a name you can't say without your jaw tightening —
that's the door. That's your Tuesday.
Go before the phone does.

Mm. (the driveway)
Mm. (the coat)
(go before the phone does)

We made it right —
two gray men crying in fluorescent light.
Eleven years dissolved in one "I'm sorry" —
don't wait for the phone call. Make it right.

He's coming for Thanksgiving.
Bringing Mama's roll recipe. We both had it all along.
(we made it right)

Lyrics written by Rob Matare. Written by me • made with AI. Artist visuals are digitally created.

More from Keys Under the Mat

  1. 1Cardboard Castle3:59
  2. 2The Metronome4:14
  3. 3The Last Page Was Blank4:45
  4. 4One More Chorus5:39
  5. 5Keys Under the Mat5:34
  6. 6Steel in the Spine5:00
  7. 7Let the Light Stay4:50
  8. 8Hold the Floor3:49
  9. 9Zahra, You Left With the Moon4:17
  10. 10One Chair Empty3:11
  11. 12Restart My Heart3:33
  12. 13Room for Joy3:34
  13. 14Built a House Across the Ocean3:48
  14. 15First Snow Video3:32
  15. 16Perfectly Unmade3:29
  16. 17Last Year's Sneakers3:49
  17. 18One Suitcase3:51
  18. 19Hair Grows Back3:11
  19. 20Can't Lie3:29
  20. 21Round We Go4:15
  21. 22Borderless3:00
  22. 23Slow on the Cobblestone4:10
  23. 24Number by Heart4:36

Previews provided courtesy of iTunes. Listen on Apple Music